Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Covenant Marriage Law -- worthy investment?

The thought of divorce never crosses our minds when we walk up to say I Do's to the love of our life, but as reality sets in, sometimes that word never leaves our mind. According to a recent article in the Miami News-Record, divorce costs state-government millions and millions of dollars annually (see http://www.miaminewsrecord.com/articles/2010/01/14/news/doc4b4fafe3d193c245225626.txt) The effects of divorce are domino in nature -- it can have many detrimental effects for the family and children involved. Say for instance your mom divorces your dad (a common thing nowadays) and your mom is left with a small child support check and has to go out and get a full time job. She doesn't make quite enough to support you and your siblings so she turns to the government for Medicaid and food stamps, which she qualifies for because she is at or below the considered poverty level. Your mom struggles and you are in a lower-income home. This puts you at risk for poverty living as an adult yourself. This also makes you 12 times more likely to be incarcerated, three times more to be expelled, and 7 times more likely to live in poor living conditions. You are also more susceptible to abuse illegal substances and develop mental health diseases.
Many state governments recognize that the high rate of divorce is costing them so much money they are stepping up and attempting to regulate morality. In the states of Louisiana, Arkansas, and Arizona, state governments are offering monetary rewards for premarital counseling and are offering couples that are tying the knot the option of signing a covenant marriage license.
This type of marriage license has many pros and cons .
Pros can include:
  • Premarital counseling and counseling before ending in divorce
  • No-fault divorce isn't an option
  • A potential for lengthy divorce process which would in turn discourage the involving couple and possiblt cause them to re-evaluate the reasoning behind divorce.
  • Divorce could have a more costly influence on the couple thus continuing to discourage the couple

Cons include:

  • Religious in nature, as described by some critics
  • There are three only acceptable reasons for divorce: felony, abuse, adultery and even so if it isn't prove (jail time doesn't count) the abused spouse may be forced to stay with the spouse.
  • The couple may go to another state not recognizing the covenant marriage law and get a divorce.
  • Court may not look twice at you if you file for divorce unless you have two years of separation and have proof you haven't been living together.
  • It gives more authority to the government to regulate your marriage.

You can read one lady's scary story:

"Abuse has to be proven, and it seems only physical abuse is acceptable AND only IF the spouse is beating you up in court. Adultery, the courts will just mandate counseling for two years, and even after the counseling, if one spouse doesn't want a divorce...guess what? You must stay married. Felony, there has to be actual jail time."

"The guy I was married to informed me that as long as he doesn't hit me with a closed fist, it is NOT abuse. And it would not result in a felony arrest. And even if it DID, as long as HE didn't want to divorce, guess what? I would not get a divorce. And this is how the courts here are interpreting the law. It is scary and frightening."

"Not only that, but in cases such as mine, the future bride to be is emotionally blackmailed into a covenant marriage because "obviously you dont think this will work out and you don't love me enough and you must not want our marriage to work."

To read further in detail about Covenant Marriage Laws in the participating states you are incouraged to read this the details about the laws are enlightening.

While the sadness of high divorce rates still continue I think that perhaps steps should be taken prior to marriage. Making divorce more difficult to obtain can potentially block abused women (or men) from getting out of a dangerous situation. Lets look more into premarital counseling or maybe longer engagements. Nip the problem in the bud before it can happen. Either way the high divorce rates have a scary effect on our society and our economy. Who wants to be a statistic? If you are afraid then don't marry that person. Get advice from your parents or someone else you respect. Love is blinding. Reality is not.

5 comments:

  1. This was a very good story. I see both sides to this. Having a covenant marriage license could be a good thing or bad thing. Good because people won't rush to get married, and even make people second guess being stuck with one person the rest of their lives. Bad because of the story listed. Abused women can't prove some of the abuse so they can't get a divorce by choice. I'm just lucky I have a wonderful husband and don't need to think about a divorce for us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the enlightenment. I agree, the possibility of divorce should be addressed even before marriage. How this could be done would have been an excellent way to go further with this topic. I hope you have a peace-filled week.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow. I had never heard much about covenant marriages, but they sound like they could turn into a real horror story. I believe that all couples that are engaged should definitely seek out pre-marital counseling, but I'm not too sure how I feel about the the government regulation. Especially in the case of abuse, which can often times be hard to prove.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That is a scary law. I agree with the whole marriage counseling before marriage. I was abused for 6-7 years and was never hit. He stuck needles through me, aimed guns at me and our baby, and was suicidal if I did anything that displeased him. I did the woman's work...and then I did the man's work. I put on a fake smile everywhere we went, and I think I beat the odds getting away from him (after he molested my under-aged little sister). Which also can't be proven because too much time has passed, and she was too afraid to speak up when it counted. No, this is not a safe law at all!

    ReplyDelete
  5. This was a very interesting blog. And my boyfriend wonders why I have a problem with commiting to a date to wed. I tell him I only plan to be married once and though it seems now like we maybe together forever I just want to be sure. We have been together for three years and have a daughter. Maybe Im being unreasonable.

    ReplyDelete